Law 5 -Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellum

Si vis
pacem, para
” (i.e., “who wants peace, prepares for war”) is a Latin adage adapted from a statement found in Book 3 of the Roman author Publius Flavius Vegetius Renatus’s “tract De Re Militari” (fourth or fifth century). Many centuries before, Chinese General Sun Tsu has already claimed in his famous treaty “The Art of War”:

He will win who, prepared himself, waits to take the enemy unprepared.

Cyber security is a war between two opponents. On one side, the security designers and practitioners defend assets. On the other, cyber hackers attempt to steal, impair or destroy these assets. Most of the traditional rules of warfare apply to cyber security. Thus, “The Art of War” is a pamphlet that any security practitioner should have read.

Be proactive; a static target is easier to defeat than a dynamic one. Security defense should be active rather than reactive where possible. Furthermore, security is aging. Thus, the defenders must prepare new defenses and attempt to predict the next attacks. The next generation of defense should be available before the occurrence of any severe attacks. Of course, they must be different from the previous versions. The new defense mechanisms do not need to be deployed immediately. In most cases, their deployment may be delayed until their impact will be optimal. The optimal time may be immediately after the occurrence of an attack, or only once the loss occurred would be higher than the cost of deploying the new version. The optimal time may be when it hurts at maximum the attackers. For instance, a new generation of Pay TV smart card may be activated just before a major broadcast event.

Being proactive is also a rule for day to day defense. Do not wait for that a hack was detected to check your logs. Do not wait for an exploit to hit your system to learn about latest attacks and new tools. Do not wait for a hack to exploit unpatched systems, patch the system as soon as possible.

Design for renewability; according to Law 1, any secure system may be compromised one day. The only acceptable method to address this risk is renewable security. Every secure system must be renewable in the case of a successful hack. Without renewable security in its design, a system is doomed. Nevertheless, to ensure secure renewability, the kernel that handles renewability cannot be updated in the field. This kernel must ensure that attackers cannot misuse this renewability mechanism for their own purpose and that attackers cannot prevent the renewal. This kernel must also make sure that the attacker cannot roll back the updated system to the previously vulnerable version. One element of your trust model is probably that this kernel is secure.

Do not rest on your laurels; complacency is not an acceptable mindset for security practitioners. They must constantly be vigilant. The attackers are adapting quickly to new defenses and are creative. Some attackers are brilliant. If the defender did not detect a breach in the system, it does not necessarily mean that this system is secure. It may be that the breach has not yet been detected.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *